Practices in democratizing literature
a digital ethnography of Latin American cartonera publishing
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.22409/pragmatizes.v12i22.51322Keywords:
Cartoneras, Literary Practices, Democratization, Counter-Uses, Book-ObjectAbstract
The article focuses on some Latin American cartonera publishers, literary community-based collectives that produce and distribute hand-crafted and hand-painted, cardboard-bound books from materials collected by recycling cooperatives. Based on a digital ethnography, the aim is to analyze networks established among cartoneras from different countries, understanding them as a transnational cultural movement that, on the one hand, proposes alternative ways of producing and distributing books in non-institutionalized territories and, on the other, encourages the transformation of "non-artistic" objects into art. The paper seeks to verify to what extent the potential for artistic creativity put into practice by cartoneras has been responsible for a process of democratization of editorial and literary practices in Latin America. In the first part of the text, we describe the methodological challenges of a collective research carried out in the midst of the COVID-19 pandemic, stablishing our empirical approach and the tools used throughout the digital ethnography. Then, we consider two strategies that agents have used to confront a model of editorial and literary production that, for them, is excluding. We examine their networks of action and their collective cultural labor routines. Finally, we focused on the “book-object”, based on a discussion about counter-uses of the cardboard as a way to expand practices of democratization of the access to books, reading, and literature.
Downloads
References
Aguilera, Silvia. (2013) Políticas públicas en cultura: una condición necesaria para la democratización del libro y la bibliodiversidad. Comunicación y Medios 27: 147-157.
Arranz, Beatriz M. (2013) “¡Fuerza Cartonera! Un estudio sobre la cultura editorial cartonera y su comunicación.”. Tesis. Universidad de Valladolid.
Becker, Howard. (1977) “Mundos artísticos e tipos sociais”. In: Velho, Gilberto. Arte e sociedade. Rio de Janeiro: Zahar, p. 9-26.
Bell, Lucy. (2017a) “Las cosas se pueden hacer de modo distinto”: understanding concepts of locality, resistance, and autonomy in the cardboard publishing movement, Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies, 26(2): 51–72.
_____. (2018) Place, people and processes in waste theory: a Global South critique, Cultural Studies, 33(1): 98-121.
_____. (2017b). “Recycling materials, recycling lives: cardboard publishers in Latin America”. In: Johns-Putra, L. Squire, and J. Parham, eds. Literature and sustainability: exploratory essays. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 76–96.
_____; O’Hare, Patrick. (2019) Latin American politics underground: Networks, rhizomes and resistance in cartonera publishing, International Journal of Cultural Studies 23(1): 20-41.
Bilbija, Ksenija. (2014) El valor de un cartonero en el mercado cultural. CILHA 15(2): 137-155.
_____; Carbajal, Paloma Celis, eds. (2009) Akademia Cartonera: Un ABC de las editoriales cartoneras en América Latina. Madison: Parallel/University of Wisconsin-Madison Libraries.
Bonelli, Johanna Maldovan. (2014) De la autonomía a la asociatividad: la organización del trabajo cartonero “en calle” en cooperativas de la Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Revista del Centro de Estudios de Sociología del Trabajo, 6: 77-109.
Canclini, Néstor García. (2014) El mundo entero como lugar extraño. México: Gedisa,
_____. (2003) Quien habla y en qué lugar: sujetos simulados e interculturalidad. Estudos de Literatura Brasileira Contemporânea, 22: 15-37.
_____. (2005) Todos tienen cultura: ¿quiénes pueden desarrollarla? Conferencia para el Seminario sobre Cultura y Desarrollo. Washington: Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo.
Canosa, Daniel. (2017) Editoriales cartoneras: el paradigma emancipatorio de los libros cartoneros en contextos de vulnerabilidad social. In: V Encuentro Internacional de Editoriales Cartoneras, Bibliotecas Archivos y Museos (DIBAM). Biblioteca de Santiago de Chile.
Carrión, Ulises. (2012) El arte nuevo de hacer libros. México: Tumbona Ediciones.
Catonio, Angela Cristina. (2017) Do lixo à poesia: O projeto cartonero na difusão do portunhol selvagem de Douglas Diegues. Lumen et Virtus, 9(23): 58-73.
Climent-Espino, Rafael. (2020) Object-Books and Exposed Writings: New Textual and Literary Landscapes in Latin America and Spain. Anais do Museu Paulista: História e Cultura Material 28: 1-29.
Colleu, Gilles. (2007) Editores independents: da idade da razão à ofensiva? O editor independente de criação, um ator maior da bibliodiversidade. Rio de Janeiro: Libre.
Fanjul, Adrián Pablo. (2016) Malha Fina Cartonera: novidade e projeto formador. Alea, 18(2): 369-374.
Ferraz, Cláudia Pereira. (2019) A etnografia digital e os fundamentos da Antropologia para estudos em redes on-line. Revista de Arte Aurora 12(35): 46-69.
Flynn, Alex; Bell, Lucy. (2019) Returning to Form: Anthropology, Art and a Trans-Formal Methodological Approach. Anthrovision 7(1): 1-24.
Harrison, Sarah K. (2016) Waste matters: urban margins in contemporary literature. New York, NY: Routledge.
Hine, Christine. (2015) Ethnography for the internet: embedded, embodied and everyday. Huntingdon: Bloomsbury Publishing.
Holmes, Tori. (2017) Giving Visibility to Urban Change in Rio de Janeiro Through Digital Audio-Visual Culture: A Brazilian Web documentary Project and its Circulation. Journal of Urban Cultural Studies, 4(1-2): 63-85.
_____. (2016) Reframing the Favela, Remapping the City: Territorial Embeddedness and (Trans) Locality in “Framing Content” on Brazilian Favela Blogs, Journal of Latin American Cultural Studies, 25(2): 297-319.
_____. (2012) The Travelling Texts of Local Content: Following Content Creation, Communication and Dissemination via Internet Platforms in a Brazilian Favela, Hispanic Issues Online, 9: 263-288.
Johns-Putra, Adeline et al., eds. (2017) Literature and Sustainability: Concept, Text and Culture. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Kudaibergen, Jania. (2015) Las editoriales cartoneras y los procesos de empoderamiento en la industria creativa mexicana, Cuadernos Americanos, 152: 127–146.
La Fuente, Eduardo de. (2019) Tanto... quanto: sobre a necessidade de uma sociologia “textural” da arte. Caderno CRH 32(87): 475-490.
Leite, Rogerio Proença. (2002) Contra-usos e espaço público: notas sobre a construção social dos lugares na Manguetown. RBCS, 17(49): 115-134.
Lima, Andrea Terra. (2009) A estética do (in)desejável: uma margem catadora. Dissertação de Mestrado em Letras: UFRGS.
Ludmer, Josefina. (2009) Literaturas postautónomas 2.01, Propuesta Educativa 32: 41-45.
Marcus, George E. (1995) Ethnography in/of the World System: The Emergence of Multi-Sited Ethnography. Annual Review of Anthropology, 24: 95-117.
Marcuse, Herbert. (2007) A Dimensão Estética. São Paulo: Edições 70.
Meza, Aurelio. (2014) Editoriales cartoneras: hacia una posible genealogía, Radiador Magazine, abril de 2014, 62-83.
Miller, Daniel. (2020) Como conduzir uma etnografia durante o isolamento social. Blog do Sociofilo. Disponível em: https://blogdolabemus.com/2020/05/23/notas-sobre-a-pandemia-como-conduzir-uma-etnografia-durante-o-isolamento-social-por-daniel-miller
Muniz Jr., José de Souza. (2016). Girafas e bonsais: editores “independentes” na Argentina e no Brasil (1991-2015). Tese (Doutorado em Sociologia), USP, São Paulo.
_____; Oliveira, Lucas Amaral de. (2015) Literature from the Periphery of São Paulo at the Buenos Aires International Book Fair. Journal of Arts Management, Law, and Society, 45: 119-133.
Nascimento, Erica P. (2009) Vozes marginais na literatura. Rio de Janeiro: Aeroplano.
Nicolau Netto, Michel. (2012) O discurso da diversidade: a definição da diferença a partir da World Music. Tese (Doutorado em Sociologia). UNICAMP, Campinas.
Oliveira, Lucas Amaral de. (2020) Experiências estéticas em movimento. Rio de Janeiro: Ape’ku.
_____. (2017) Speaking for themselves: observations on a “marginal” tradition in Brazilian Literature. Brasiliana - Journal for Brazilian Studies, 5(1): 441-471.
_____; Pardue, Derek. (2018) City as Mobility, Vibrant, 14(3): 282-305.
Palomino, Héctor. (2003) Las experiencias actuales de autogestión en Argentina. Entre la informalidad y la economía social. Nueva Sociedad, 184: 115-128.
Pardue, Derek. (2015). Cape Verde, Let’s Go: Creole Rappers and Citizenship in Portugal. Champaign: University of Illinois Press.
Perelman, Mariano Daniel; Boy, Martín. (2010) Cartoneros en Buenos Aires: nuevas modalidades de encuentro. Revista Mexicana de Sociología 72(3): 393-418.
Reyes, Jesús Cano. (2011) ¿Un nuevo boom latinoamericano? La explosión de las editoriales cartoneras. Espéculo: Revista de Estudios Literarios, 47. Disponível em: http://webs.ucm.es/info/especulo/numero47/boomlati.html.
Rose, Deborah Bird. (2003). “Decolonizing the discourse of environmental knowledge in settler societies. In: G. Hawkins and S. Muecke, eds. Culture and waste. Lanham: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers, 53–72.
Salom, Julio Souto. (2014) La literatura marginal periférica y el silencio de la crítica, Revista Chilena de Literatura, 88: 235-264.
Serrano, Mary Luz E. (2014) Una escritura propia: Anotaciones sobre literatura marginal en Brasil, Revista Chilena de Literatura, 88: 95-111.
Shapiro, Roberta. (2007) O que é artificação? Sociedade & Estado 22(1): 135-151.
_____; Heinich, Nathalie. (2013) Quando há artificação?, Sociedade & Estado, 28(1): 14-28.
Silva, Filipe Carreira da; Vieira, Mónica Brito. (2019) The Politics of The Book: a study on the materiality of ideas. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University Press.
Silva, Mário Augusto Medeiros da. (2013) A descoberta do insólito: literatura negra e literatura periférica no Brasil (1960-2000). Rio de Janeiro: Aeroplano.
Smith, Christen A. (2015) A Escrita “Uterina Preta” de Mjiba: Elizandra Souza and the New Black Female Poets of Brazil, Latin American Cultural Studies, 24(3): 405-441.
Sorá, Gustavo. (2017) Editar desde la izquierda en América Latina: la agitada historia del Fondo de Cultura Económica y de Siglo XXI. Buenos Aires: Siglo Veintiuno Editores.
Tennina, Lucía. (2010) Paratextos y “saraus” de poesía: Mecanismos de legitimación de la escritura y del escritor “periféricos”. Darandina, 3(2): 2-11.
Tiburcio, Eleuterio O; Candelario, Juana Z. (2014) Libros cartoneros: una alternativa para la integración a la cultura escrita, Revista de Educación y Cultura AZ, 88: 32-37.
Vila, Adrián R. (2016) Ediciones Cartoneras latinoamericanas en tiempos de transposición a digital, Revista Chilena de Literatura, 94: 119-143.
Vilhena, Flavia Krauss de. (2017) O acontecimento Eloísa Cartonera: memória e identificações. São Paulo: Novas Edições Acadêmicas.
_____. (2015) Sobre o entremeio: a escritura dos manifestos presentes em Akademia Cartonera, Malha Fina Cartonera. Disponível em: https://goo.gl/BfwsoS.
Zolberg, Vera. (2006) O objeto de arte como processo social. In: Para uma sociologia das artes. São Paulo: Ed. SENAC, p. 131-166.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
By forwarding an original to PragMATIZES, the authors agree that the copyright related to it is transferred to the Publishing. Articles and other writings are made available in PDF format from their publication, and they can be downloaded to institutional repositories and personal pages, provided that with their proper bibliographic indication.